Of everything a seller decides, price matters most. It shapes who sees your home, how many people show up, and how strong your offers are. Get it right and the rest of the sale gets easier. Get it wrong and you spend weeks trying to catch up.
Here's how I think about pricing, and why I push back when a seller wants to "test the market."
Why the first weeks matter most
When your home goes live, it gets a burst of attention. Buyers who have been searching for a while get an alert. Agents who have been waiting for the right house for their clients take a look. Your listing is new, and new gets noticed.
That attention doesn't last. After a few weeks, the buyers who were going to look have looked. Your listing slides down the search results. New homes come on and take the spotlight.
So the first weeks are your best chance. If the price is right, that early attention turns into showings and offers. If it's too high, the people most ready to buy look at the price, compare it to everything else they've seen, and move on.
How a real comparative analysis works
A comparative market analysis, or CMA, is how I build a price. It's not a guess, and it's not an online estimate. It's a careful look at what buyers actually paid for homes like yours, near yours, recently.
Here's what goes into it.
Recent nearby sales
I start with homes that sold recently in your neighborhood, as close to your street as possible. Sold prices tell us what buyers actually paid. Active listings show the competition, but asking prices are only hopes until someone pays them.
Similar homes, honestly compared
No two houses are the same, so I adjust for the differences:
- Size, layout, bedrooms and bathrooms
- Lot size and how the lot is used
- Parking, garage and basement
- Location details, like a busy street or a quiet block
Condition and updates
This is where most of the real difference lives. A house with an updated kitchen and newer systems competes differently than one that needs work. I walk your home in person, because photos and public records don't tell the whole story.
- Kitchens and bathrooms
- Roof, heating, cooling and water heater
- Windows, floors and finishes
- Anything a buyer would need to repair or replace soon
The current market
Then I look at what's happening right now in your town: how much is for sale, how quickly homes are going under contract, and what buyers are reacting to. That tells us whether to price right at the comps, or position a little differently to stand out.
The result is a price range backed by real sales, with a clear reason for where we land in it.
Why "testing the market" usually backfires
I understand the instinct. "Let's start high. We can always come down." It feels like it costs nothing. In my experience, it costs a lot.
- The best buyers skip you. Buyers and their agents know the market. A high price filters your home out of searches and off shortlists.
- You make other homes look good. Overpriced homes often help sell the fairly priced homes nearby.
- Time on market becomes a story. The longer a home sits, the more buyers wonder what's wrong with it.
- Price cuts don't bring back the first wave. When you lower the price, you get a second look, but not the same excitement as day one.
- You may end up with less. Homes that start too high often end up selling below where they would have landed if they had been priced right from the start.
Pricing right isn't leaving money on the table. It's putting your home in front of the most buyers at the moment they're paying the most attention.
Pricing and preparation go together
Price works best when the home is ready. That's why I build pricing into a five-part plan: presentation, repairs, paperwork, timing, and decisions. A home that looks cared for, comes with answers and has a clear price gets taken seriously.
Over my last 19 sales, my sellers have averaged 100.33% of list price. That number comes from pricing with real data, preparing the home well, and being ready when the right offer comes in.
A quick checklist before you set a price
- Ask to see the actual recent sales behind any price suggestion.
- Ask how condition and updates were accounted for.
- Be wary of any price that seems designed to win your listing instead of selling your home.
- Agree on a plan for the first weeks: what feedback we'll watch for and when we'll talk about adjusting.
Let's find your number
If you want to know what your home could sell for, I'll put together a real comparative analysis for you, based on recent sales near you and the condition of your home. Start with a free home value, or read more about how I sell homes. No pressure. Just an honest number and the reasons behind it.
Thinking about selling?
Get a real number for your home, based on recent sales near you.
What is my home worth?


