People often come to me with two towns on their list: Cranford and Westfield. Both are in Union County. Both have a real downtown built around a train station on NJ Transit's Raritan Valley Line. Both share Lenape Park along the Rahway River. From a distance they can look alike. Up close they are different places, and the right one depends on what you need.

I am not going to pick a winner. Here is how I would compare them.

Size and setting

Cranford is a township of about 4.87 square miles, about 18 miles southwest of New York City. It is nicknamed "The Venice of New Jersey" because the Rahway River winds through town.

Westfield is a town of about 6.7 square miles, about 16 miles southwest of New York City. It sets aside 211 acres for parks. The rail line and Route 28 split Westfield into a North Side and a South Side, and you will hear people use those terms.

The train and the commute

Both stations are on the Raritan Valley Line, so the basic shape of the trip is similar. The details differ.

  • Cranford station: about 20 minutes to Newark Penn Station and about 49 minutes to New York Penn Station.
  • Westfield station: most trains run between High Bridge and Newark Penn, and a limited number run directly to New York Penn. Rush-hour express trains take about 50 minutes to New York Penn and about 20 minutes to Newark Penn. The station has 711 parking spaces and two historic depots linked by a passenger tunnel.

Buses matter too. Cranford has NJ Transit routes 56, 57, 58, 59, 66, 112 and 113, plus the 113X express to the Port Authority Bus Terminal in about 40 minutes. Westfield has Route 113 to Port Authority in about an hour, Routes 114 and 117 along Route 22, and Route 59 between Plainfield and Newark.

By car, Cranford has Parkway Interchanges 136 and 137, with Route 28 running through the center of town. Westfield has Route 28, County Routes 509 and 610, U.S. Route 22, and Parkway Exits 135 and 137.

My tip: ride the train from both stations at your real commute time before you decide. Schedules change, and how a trip feels at 7:15 on a Tuesday is what counts.

The downtowns

Downtown Cranford centers on North Avenue, North Union Avenue, South Avenue, Walnut Avenue and Miln Street around the station. Look for Eastman Plaza and its clock, the Victorian-style lighting and paver sidewalks, and more than 50 food establishments. Cranford created what is considered New Jersey's first special improvement district downtown in 1985. There is also recent transit-oriented development, including the South Avenue riverfront redevelopment.

Downtown Westfield is larger. The town describes it as having more than 450 stores, restaurants and services. The Downtown Westfield Corporation manages the special improvement district, and downtown won the Great American Main Street Award in 2004. The Rialto Theater downtown appeared on the NBC series Ed.

On a visit, walk both on the same day. Notice how far the shops are from the homes you like, and where you would park.

Parks and the river

Cranford's identity is tied to the Rahway River. The Rahway River Parkway, designed in the 1920s by the Olmsted Brothers, runs through town. Nomahegan Park has a lake, fields and paved paths along the river. The Cranford Canoe Club, built in 1908, rents canoes and kayaks. Township parks include Hanson Park, McConnell Park, Unami Park and the Cranford Riverwalk.

Westfield's parks include Mindowaskin Park on Broad Street, about 12.6 acres with a large pond and a gazebo, plus Brightwood Park, Tamaques Park, Gumbert Park (home of the Westfield Rink) and others. The Westfield Memorial Pool and Aquatic Complex has a 50-meter main pool, a diving pool and two water slides. Membership sold out for the 2026 season.

Lenape Park, about 450 acres, spans both towns.

If you are buying near the river in either town, ask about flood zone status and flood insurance for that specific address. It is a normal question, and the answer belongs in your decision.

Historic homes and what they mean for you

Both towns have historic housing, and the rules are not the same.

In Cranford, Sunny Acres is a community of 172 homes built 1940-1943 by the Sears Modern Homes Division, mostly Cape Cod and Colonial Revival designs. It became Cranford's first Local Historic District in 2018. Original streets include Algonquin Drive and Oneida Drive.

In Westfield, the town says many homes are Victorian or Colonial in style. Stoneleigh Park is on the National Register, but it has no local landmark status. As of the 2024 master plan element, only the Kimball Avenue district and 23 individual properties are locally designated, and those fall under the Historic Preservation Commission.

Questions to ask in either town

  1. Is this address in a locally designated historic district or a local landmark?
  2. If so, what exterior changes need approval?
  3. What permits exist for past renovations?
  4. Is the home in a flood zone?

Schools, by name

Cranford Township Public Schools runs PreK-12, with Cranford High School for grades 9-12. Union College of Union County has its main campus in Cranford.

Westfield Public Schools runs 10 schools, from Lincoln Early Childhood Center through Westfield High School. Always confirm which school an address is zoned for with the district.

How to choose

Make a short list of what you will do every week: commute, errands, time outside, walking to dinner. Then spend a Saturday in each town doing those things. The answer usually becomes clear.

Read my Cranford town guide and Westfield town guide for the basics. You can also browse my saved searches for Cranford homes and Westfield homes.

If you want a second opinion while you compare, call me. I am glad to walk both towns with you.

Thinking about selling?

Get a real number for your home, based on recent sales near you.

What is my home worth?

Back to the blog